Scott Trade Etf

A Look at the Short-Sale Uptick Rule

There has been quite a bit of discussion lately about short selling and the “uptick rule.”  In fact, some believe that the steps towards reinstating these rules have helped bolster stocks of late.  What is the uptick rule and why is the mere mention of doing away with said rule possibly creating a rally?  Let’s take a look.

First, a brief refresher on short selling.  The textbook definition is when an investor sells a stock that he/she doesn’t own.  The seller’s investor loans the stock in order for the investor to sell it.  At some point, the seller has to buy the same number of shares they sold short (known as “covering”) in order to return them to the broker.  Money is made when the stock that was sold short falls and is bought back at a lower price.

For most normal “retail” investors, in order to short-sell a stock, they must have a margin account and their broker must “borrow” the stock from another one of its clients long margin account — so in some cases, no stock is available to short and the retail trader is basically unable to do so.  Many Institutions / Professionals / Hedge Funds etc have not had to adhere to this method of “borrowing” in many cases in recent years, but that is a matter for a future article.  Let’s now turn our attention to the uptick rule.

The uptick rule was instituted back in 1938 (as part of the reforms following the 1927 Crash and Great Depression), stating that a stock may not be sold short unless the trade before the short sale was at a lower price than the price where the short sale is executed.  Simply put, selling short is only permissible if the stock ticks higher.  The goal of the uptick rule was to keep short sellers from compounding and accelerating a stock’s downtrend.  Note that the uptick rule does not apply to certain types of investing vehicles, including:  market exchange-traded funds (ETFs), currencies, single-stock futures, and futures (but futures do have limit-down rules — circuit breakers and limit-down rules will also be the topic of a future article).

Why did the SEC repeal the rule?  The rationale for lifting the rule was apparently a “test” by the SEC to see the effectiveness of the uptick rule.  One would also likely assume there was some lobbying by major financial firms to have it lifted.  And general de-regulation of the SEC and its powers over the past years likely contributed as well.  Based on the above chart, one could conclude the “test” didn’t work very well.  Many have attributed the incredibly rapid declines that many stocks in the Financial Sector have seen to the lack of an uptick rule — but this is a fairly complicated issue with other factors involved.

Nonetheless, recently Fed. Chairman Bernanke proposed examining re-instituting the rule, and Congress has recently acted (on March 10th, no less) to have the rule re-instated very quickly.  See the following chart for these news events in relation to the market.

Bottom Line:  Regardless of the actual effectiveness of the short-sale uptick rule (and whether it can be manipulated and/or ignored by many traders), the market performance after both the 2007 repeal and since the March 10th plans to reinstate are quite striking.  Also remember that as a retail investor, you can participate in down-side speculation and hedging without short-selling stock through the use of Put Options, Short ETFs, and various Option Strategies.

Scott Downing,
BigTrends.com
1-800-244-8736

About the Author

Visit http://bigtrendsaffiliates.com/trendwatch/ to receive articles and blogs directly in your email.

Understanding Etf Options (Hardcover) $48.85 Proven ways to increase profits while reducing risk in one of today’s fastest growing marketsFinding a safe investment in today’s markets makes looking for that needle in a haystack seem easy. With a single whale able to move a market, herds of elephants ready to stampede after it, and a global computer network executing high-frequency trades in milliseconds, an investor might think stuffing cash under a mattress is safe financial planning. But those dollars have lost about 40 percent of their buying power in the last 20 years.Understanding ETF Options is the best way to protect and grow your assets in the financial climate ahead.This hands-on guidebook gives you a unique audience with options expert Kenneth Trester, who has traded on the exchanges since their inception in 1973. This book culls his experience in systems analysis, operations research, and investment management to help you diversify risk while profiting on market volatility.Through conversational explanations and real-world examples, it lays out how ETFs offer retail investors easy access to diversified financial value and demonstrates effective techniques to acquire, safeguard, and accrue wealth by trading options on these unique securities.Whether you are an experienced investor or have never executed a trade, Understanding ETF Options can get you up and running on the exchanges with confidence and control. It comes with such essential tools as the Fair Value Option tables and covers everything you need to know to trade ETF options successfully, including:An insider’s explanation of ETFsHow to identify valuable ETFsHow to avoid rogue wavesStrategies for achieving your goals among the elephants, whales, and computersProfessional traders’ secrets for option buying and writingAs far as options are concerned, everything comes down to time and movement. Now is your time to make a move and pu

The ETF Trend Following Playbook by Lydon, Tom Edition ILL, 1 $22.99 Master the Low-Risk ETF-Based Investing Strategy That Gives You the Chance to Make Money in Any Market Climate   “Tom Lydon has been a leader in the ETF business for many years. His new book walks through the basics of ETFs investing and shows why professionals–and increasingly, individuals–are turning to ETFs.” –Bob Pisani, CNBC Reporter   “Our complex and global financial system has created a powerful need for guideposts for investors and traders alike. Tom Lydon provides an excellent tool to help navigate the current economic environment in a clear, concise, easy-to-understand way.” –John L. Jacobs, EVP and CMO, The NASDAQ OMX Group, Inc.   “There are hundreds of writers, speakers, and advisers clamoring to get a seat aboard the ETF bandwagon. However, if you’re looking for genuine insight from a real pioneer, then read Tom Lydon. Not only is Tom’s The ETF Trend Following Playbook a principled how-to guide for individual investors, it is requisite reading for money managers.” –Gary Gordon, Editor of ETFExpert.com   “Tom Lydon has put together a concise handbook for the active ETF trader outlining the key drivers of successful trend investing. The ETF Trend Following Playbook provides sound advice for traders as well as a comprehensive and up-to-date tour of all the ETF world has to offer.” –Scott Burns, Director of ETF Analysis at Morningstar